I've been looking forward for the last couple of days to go to Piece, a New Haven style pizza restaurant and brewery in the deep dish land of Chicago. However, upon arrival, I was informed by one of the most stereotypical hipsters I've ever seen that the wait was an hour and a half, which my friends and I weren't willing to deal with. Also, for anybody interested in having a growler filled at Piece, we learned that they don't fill other brewery's growlers.
Luckily, I'd anticipated this as a potential issue, and knew that The Art Of Pizza wasn't too far away. As I'd been meaning to try The Art Of Pizza for an extremely long time, I was more than happy to make the ten or so minute drive over and start anew. Arriving, it wasn't at all what I expected. Unlike the table service deep dish pizzerias that I was used to, this was a more grungy restaurant similar to most non-deep dish places I've been. As someone who's really only concerned with taste, not decorum, I was unfazed. We entered with high hopes.
The Art Of Pizza serves thin crust, stuffed crust, and pan pizzas. You can purchase either an entire pie or pizza by the slice. I ordered two slices, which were conveniently priced such that they were $4 each post-tax. I got a slice of cheese stuffed pizza, to try the style, and a slice of sausage pan pizza, to compare against other deep dish establishments I've eaten at on a more even playing ground.
I started with the sausage. Overall, I was surprised to be unimpressed. I thought that the sausage was less savory than other deep dish sausages, and was more reminiscent of the sausage used elsewhere in the country. The sauce was good and well proportioned, but I felt there wasn't quite enough cheese for my liking. The crust beneath the cheese was relatively thin an didn't play a huge part in the flavor. I thought the strongest component of the pizza was the (end) crust. It had a crunchy exterior with a firm interior, and had enough delicious greasy flavor that I'd be happy eating it on its own.
I then moved on to the cheese stuffed pizza slice. I enjoyed this one a lot more. The slice was significantly thicker, and I think most of that came from the addition of cheese, making it better proportioned than the pan slice. In what I consider good stuffed style, the top of the slice held its shape while the cheese in the middle stretched out with every bite. I found the crust similar to the pan pizza. Though it was thicker, particularly at the extremities, I found the additional volume welcome.
Conclusively, while I thoroughly enjoyed The Art Of Pizza and would happily return, I would not include it in the top tier of Chicago pizza restaurants.